NPS vs. Other Retirement Plans

NPS
PPF
Fixed Deposits
Insurance
(Endowment/ULIPs)
Mutual Funds
Purpose
Retirement savings
Long-term savings
Short to medium - term savings
Life cover + savings
Short, medium and long term options
Lock-in Period
Until retirement (60 years)
15 years
Depends on the tenure of the deposit
Depends on the Policy term
No specific lock-in (except ELSS)
Withdrawals
Limited (after 60 years; partial after 3 years for specific purposes)
Partial after 5 years; full after 15 years
FDs can be broken but may incur penalty
Varies as per policy terms
Anytime (except ELSS)
Returns
Market-linked
PPF Interest rates are fixed quarterly by Government of India
Fixed (depends on bank rates)
Varies (depends on plan)
Market-linked (varies depending on the scheme)
Tax Benefits
Yes, under Sections 80C, 80CCD(1B) and 80 CCB (2)
Yes, under Section 80C
Tax benefits only for 5-year FD under Section 80C
Yes, under Section 80C
Yes, under Section 80C for ELSS
Risk
Depends on investment choice
Low
Low
Depends on plan
Varies depending on the scheme invested in
Annuity Options
Yes (upon maturity)
No
No
Yes (if it's an endowment)
No
Previous Next